Forums | Search | Archives

 All Forums
 Cool Edit
 Eliminating Low Freq Clicks & Pops (Neg Spikes)
 
Author  Topic 
KenGAce





Posts: 166


Post Posted - Mon Apr 02, 2001 12:40 pm 

This may have been discussed already somewhere in the depths of the forum. I've been trying to get rid of low frequency clicks and pops that sound more like dull thuds due to small bumps in the vinyl. On the frequency spectrum, they appear as negative (direction) spikes. For some reason CE Pro doesn't detect/correct these as readily/easily as the more common high frequency (positive) spikes. Has anyone discovered a way to get rid of these neg spikes? I thought about inverting the signal (and possibly provide some amplification) so that the neg become positive spikes and then do a de-click on the signal. Thanks.
Go back to top
seanbaker





Posts: 228


Post Posted - Mon Apr 02, 2001 1:21 pm 

I don't knwo if these thuds are the same as what I've encountered before, but I simply went in and removed the bass in those areas.

_________________
“You were born an original. Don’t die a copy.”

www.seanbaker.com
Jingles - Retropolis Music

www.foursexes.com
Space Age Pop Band

www.leisurekings.com
Far-out Polyester Lounge Act
Go back to top
beetle


Location: USA


Posts: 2591


Post Posted - Mon Apr 02, 2001 10:10 pm 

I use the scientific filter. Just keep adjusting the high pass filtering until the thud is removed without harming the music.
Go back to top
urumuqi74





Posts: 1038


Post Posted - Tue Apr 03, 2001 6:25 am 


Well Ken, you brought up a nice thread here. In art of restoring vinyl, there's 2 gray areas for which I need more "practice".

The first was the bump (vertical) until I read Beetle's comments. That should do it after I register the add-in!!!


The other one is the "horizontal sway" sound which is more likely an off centered vinyl. The stylus will at one point hit the groove wall producing this high freq. noisy hiss. Almost like the end of the record loop sound without the pop. Can't be removed with the hiss or noise reduction features without harming the real audio. I am cooking something with noise reduction and dynamic processing but it's rather primitive at this point.

Anyone with a miracle cure for this?

_________________
The truth is out there!
Go back to top
beetle


Location: USA


Posts: 2591


Post Posted - Tue Apr 03, 2001 10:50 am 

To correct off center 45's I just don't use the 45 adapter and align the record by hand until it the grooves are even.

LP's present a much tougher problem. In some cases I elevate the LP high enough on the turntable to where it won't sit down on the spindle and adjust it to eliminate the wow. It get's tricky because if the album is warped the tone arm won't track it very well. I have resoored several LP's this way.
Go back to top
urumuqi74





Posts: 1038


Post Posted - Tue Apr 03, 2001 11:13 am 

Ok Beetle, if i understand it well, in the case of horizontal sway:

-you elevate the lp to a certain point so you create a kind of opposition to the sway.
The needle won't go it the groove wall as much as if it's play full flat on the plater.


I wil try that, quite tricky though!!!

_________________
The truth is out there!
Go back to top
beetle


Location: USA


Posts: 2591


Post Posted - Wed Apr 04, 2001 3:34 am 

The reason for elevating the record is so that you can move the LP around in order to correct the off-center pressing.

Yes, the stylus (needle) may noe track the record as well but doing this may be the only way to get a good pass out of an off center record.

If you're like me, hearing even a small amount of wow or flutter can drive you up the wall! It's like being cursed with perfect pitch, which I am!
Go back to top
urumuqi74





Posts: 1038


Post Posted - Wed Apr 04, 2001 9:06 am 

Quote:
If you're like me, hearing even a small amount of wow or flutter can drive you up the wall! It's like being cursed with perfect pitch, which I am!



Yes, especially that a pair of headphones, even good ones, have the tendency to amplify these defects.

_________________
The truth is out there!
Go back to top
Frank Burnett





Posts: 16


Post Posted - Wed Apr 04, 2001 9:53 am 

Beetle or Urumqui
I'm still learning so please pardon my dumb question. I have heard the terms "flutter and wow" before but what is it exactly? Thanks for your patience....
Go back to top
Syntrillium M.D.


Location: USA


Posts: 5124


Post Posted - Wed Apr 04, 2001 10:02 am 

Hello Frank. This really relates mostly to analog tape, but can be heard on turntables with [unwanted] varispeed. By definition, 'Wow' is a product of slow-speed variations in a tape-transport system causing a taffy-like sound quality, ie, slurred, varying pitch (sometimes), dragging and a generally 'muddied' lower mid-range.

'Flutter' is the result of rapid-speed variations in a tape-transport system causing a fluttery sound, typically experienced in the high-mids and high freq. bands.


--Syntrillium Support

Edited by - syntrillium support on 04/04/2001 10:05:20 AM

_________________

Go back to top
invader9000





Posts: 299


Post Posted - Wed Apr 04, 2001 10:03 am 

Wow and Flutter is a term for LPs and cassetes and describes the pitch changes of audio, related to instant speed changes to the record rotation or casette tape pass in front of the heads. This is a problem to LPs and cassetes, but not an issue to CD's.
Go back to top
Frank Burnett





Posts: 16


Post Posted - Wed Apr 04, 2001 10:34 am 

Quote:
Wow and Flutter is a term for LPs and cassetes and describes the pitch changes of audio, related to instant speed changes to the record rotation or casette tape pass in front of the heads. This is a problem to LPs and cassetes, but not an issue to CD's.
[Thanks, Invader.....]
Go back to top
Frank Burnett





Posts: 16


Post Posted - Wed Apr 04, 2001 10:36 am 

Quote:
Hello Frank. This really relates mostly to analog tape, but can be heard on turntables with [unwanted] varispeed. By definition, 'Wow' is a product of slow-speed variations in a tape-transport system causing a taffy-like sound quality, ie, slurred, varying pitch (sometimes), dragging and a generally 'muddied' lower mid-range.

'Flutter' is the result of rapid-speed variations in a tape-transport system causing a fluttery sound, typically experienced in the high-mids and high freq. bands.

Thanks Syntt.........I can tell a trained ear is a must in good restoration.......


--Syntrillium Support

Edited by - syntrillium support on 04/04/2001 10:05:20 AM
[Thanks,Synt............../quote]

Edited by - frank Burnett on 04/04/2001 10:50:04 AM
Go back to top
KenGAce





Posts: 166


Post Posted - Wed Apr 04, 2001 12:34 pm 

If you have a turntable that has or had a changer built-in (record changers, ughh!) these often came with a removeable long spindle for stacking records or a short one for single play. By simply removing the spindle, you can position the record around the hole to obtain the best centering possible. Unfortunately though most of these units were not of the best quality including the tonearm, platter, and cartridge, but there were some decent ones. DUAL used to make changers with decent components in the late 70s and early 80s. My parents have one with removeable spindles and a headshell that allows you to fit the cartridge of your choice.

Edited by - KenGAce on 04/04/2001 12:36:33 PM
Go back to top
urumuqi74





Posts: 1038


Post Posted - Wed Apr 04, 2001 12:59 pm 


I remember those!!! My first introduction to hi-fi!!! Some of these turntable had pretty bouncy spring kit as well!!!

_________________
The truth is out there!
Go back to top
younglove





Posts: 314


Post Posted - Fri Apr 06, 2001 4:09 am 

I thought the "horizontal sway" sound is
actually a vertical sway due to warping of
the record and the stylus riding up and down.

For the dull thud, try using the Fill Single Click Now button of the Click/Pop Eliminator
using a high FFT size (512).

Elevating a record without compensation in the tonearm will wreak havok with the VTA
(vertical tracking angle) and VTF (vertical tracking force). Something to weigh against
the off-center correction.
Go back to top
urumuqi74





Posts: 1038


Post Posted - Fri Apr 06, 2001 6:11 am 


Younglove is right about the VTA and VTF. It will unbalanced the tonearm. I won't use the elevation technique on a whole record unless it is the last copy in the world!!!

However, elevating the record is a "last resort" attempt when no CE tools have succeded to remove the sway sound "silence__sssshhhhSSSHHHHHsssshhhh_silence___ssshhhSSSHHHssshhh".

The vertical sway, "thud" or "thump" sound is easier to remove with CE than its horizontal counterpart.

_________________
The truth is out there!
Go back to top
   Topic 
Page:


Powered by phpBB 2.0.11 © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group